Peet Brits

Hmm, but that doesn't make any sense…

  • Categories

  • Archives

  • Advertisements


Posted by Peet Brits on September 7, 2008



After seeing yet another sample of the countless arguments coming from creationists versus evolutionists, I feel I have to make a statement of my own.

I would like to start with something that my soon-to-be brother-in-law told me the other day:  “A group of people did not want to believe in God so they took some scientific evidence and started evolutionISM.  Then another group of people made the mistake of trying to counter it with the other extreme, starting creationISM.  They are both wrong.”

He has a degree in Zoology and speaks strongly against ISMs, claiming they are almost a sect of their own.  The above idea has spiralled onward and we are led to believe that we must side with either one of the two extremes: All we know has evolved in one way or another and thus God cannot exist, or there is a God which created the earth in no more than a calendar week.  Is this not a false dichotomy?

But the bible says…

When I started this weblog I wanted to avoid any religious matters, but as this is exactly what the creationists are doing I feel I need to speak their own language to really bring my point through to them.

That said; let me proceed with an example from the bible, at the point when the Israelites just got settled into their new home.  They looked at all the surrounding nations, and when they saw they all had kings they wanted one of their own.  Through the prophets the reply came that it is better not to have a single human ruler, but the people were stubborn.  You will notice that a more democratic system was proposed.  Today I believe most of us will agree that a democracy is better than a monarchy.

Now put yourself in the shoes of God.  If the idea of a more democratic human system (under the guidance of one God) was too much for them to handle, how much more difficult would it have been to touch other topics, like anti-slavery, or claiming that the earth is not flat, or going into all the details of how our world really was formed.  Is it not more likely that he said only what was needed to be said at the time?

So what about me?

Personally I do not have enough knowledge about the topic to make any real claims, but the sceptic inside of me would like to remind the reader of a very popular historic event when the people realised that the earth was round.  A group of hard-headed people with too much authority went as far as threatening to kill.  They even had a few nice scriptures to go along with it, just to soften the hearts of the people.

Is it not sad to realise that we might be repeating history?

Judging by some of the arguments I have heard lately it would seem that creationists do not argue for the sake of science, but rather because they feel threatened in their belief system.  There will always be people arguing for and against religion, but we must never allow this to stand in the way of new scientific discoveries.

I have been picking mostly on Creationists, but there are a lot of hateful comments coming from the other side of the fence as well.  Grow up people; this is really not helping anything!

So, is the earth 6,000 years old or not?  Does God exist?  That is not the point of this article.  I just want people to stop with all the silly arguments.  As mentioned before, the idea of God and evolution is not mutually exclusive.  I hope this will make people feel less emotionally threatened and more open for new possibilities.

Bringing it all together

Sometimes we are presented with extremes or loaded statements, fooling us into believing that we have a choice when we are really being fed spoons of lies.  So I will ask two things of you: do not blindly reject traditions just because you do not like them, as most of them were started for a reason, but at the same time do not blindly follow anything without questioning it in some way or another.


3 Responses to “Evolution?”

  1. Reed Braden said

    What does this have to do with my post at all?

  2. Peet Brits said

    Reed, I was referring to your creationist sample discussion. I don’t
    mind removing the link if you think it is not fitting.

    As I mentioned, and as your simple discussion suggests, the two groups
    are clearly not speaking the same language. I’m just someone on the
    sideline trying to make sense of it all.

  3. Peet Brits said

    TO SUMMARISE (from a Christian point of view):

    Two extremes:
    1) Everything was formed by evolution. There is no God.
    2) God created the earth in 6 physical days. The earth is 6000 years old.

    The more likely excluded middle:
    *) God used evolution to shape his creation. We serve a personal and creative God, how can we expect anything less?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: